When is comes to dividing the nation, are we really causing it?
[Don't you hate it when you screw up the grammar in your title, and you can't edit it or else the link is ruined? Oops. Well, it should say, "When it comes to..."]
One thing I'll constantly wonder about with how divided our country currently is is my place in it. I'm I part of the problem? If so, what have I done to become part of the problem? And is there anything that I can do to become part of the solution?
The complex answer to these three very simple questions is yes, I harbor progressive political beliefs, and no. Before I explain, think about this passage from the latest Dan Kennedy article in the Boston Phoenix, "Blue in a Red America."
If Boston — along with New York, Washington, Chicago, and Los Angeles — is one of the capitals of Blue America, the NBC exit polls describe the very definition of Red America: bigoted, intolerant, fearful of the unknown, ever ready to impose its own version of morality on everyone else. Let me admit right here that I’m struggling — much of what I’ve written about Red Americans this morning strikes me as intolerant of them. As a devoted secularist with a number of religious friends, I certainly don’t want to come off as though I’m denigrating religion itself. But the essence of liberalism is that religion must exist in its own sphere, and though it needn’t be private, it has no business poking its nose under other people’s tents. If you’re opposed to abortion, then don’t have one. If you think homosexuality is a sin, then don’t have sex with someone of the same gender. Now, this all makes perfect sense to me. The trouble is, tolerance is perhaps the most vital component of a liberal value system, and it’s at the heart of what makes Blue America what it is. And Red America values neither tolerance nor liberalism. Not to sound too arrogant, but I don’t think we would have any trouble living with them — it’s they who have trouble living with us.
And now they’ve won.
This is the best description I've found that explains, flat out, that people like me are not the problem. We are not the ones forcing this nation to become divided. How could we? We simply want to exist and that's it. People like me don't care about what happens within the walls of your church, just as long as those beliefs aren't enforced within the laws of our own home. We're not blocking out their churches like they block off abortion clinics. We're not censoring their media or banning the Bible while they constantly try to place their own standards on our media; a conquest which included suing a relatively small band called the Dead Kennedy's back in the late 80's.
For those unfamiliar with the case, here's a short rundown: The Parents Music Resource Center (PMRC), a Christian Right front group headed up by none other than Tipper Fucking Gore, started a campaign in the 80's to outright censor all the music we listen to because it didn't fit into their religious tastes. The Dead Kennedy's (DK's) were a big, but still independent punk band who were targetted by the PMRC for exactly this reason: they were independent and didn't have the resources to fight for themselves. The PMRC listed this as the main reason why they sued the DK's, by the way; picking on the little guy. The DK's latest album, Frankenchrist, included a posting of a painting by HR Giger which, essentially, was a bunch of decreped penises fucking a bunch of decreped vaginas. DK's frontman Jello Biafra said the painting symbolized the general theme of the album: society fucking itself over and over. Well, the PMRC thought this was, ahem, "harmful matter" that a child must never be subjected to, and got the Los Angeles DA to take the DK's to court over the matter. While being sued by the government, LA prosecutors made blow-ups of lyrics sheets from the album to display to the whole court while questioning witnesses, and it quickly became evident that the DK's were on trial for their political beliefs, and not for a stupid HR Giger painting. Through donations and with the help of the ACLU, there was a hung jury and the judge decided that there would be no retrial on the matter.
This is how the Christian Right operates, and these are the people who won the election. Not content with the fact that we lead different lives, their goal has always been enforcing their view of morality on us, forcing us to live like them. This is why comparisons to the Taliban, Osama bin Laden, and fundamentalist Islam are so apt.
This is also why people like me are not the problem. Unless, of course, you count living, breathing, and simply believing in a different set of beliefs as being part of the problem. I certainly don't. This is America, and if we're supposed to have freedom, then that means I can live my life any damn way I please as long as I'm not infringing on the freedoms of those around me. The undisputable fact is that these people can't live with me, not the other way around. If they were perfectly content to keep the laws of their church within their church, there wouldn't be any conflicts. It's not like I'm trying to enforce my secular views on them by suing their churches for not being secular enough.
Of course, there are plenty of Christians living in America who aren't part of the Christian Right mindset; who, like myself, wish to live their life the way they please without interfering with the lives of those who surround them and do not share their views. Not only are they our friends, but we can't take them forgranted because they are our best hope of shifting the pendulum in the church, swigning it so that liberal beliefs are respected by their majority. This will be a critical voting bloc in the 2006 and 2008 elections.
The Culture War that the Christian Right has waged on our society and liberal values has been going on for years, and it just took a turn for the worse. I honestly believe this is a crusade, and the goal is to either convert or destroy people like you and me. Unfortunately, our only hope to survive is to view this as the war it is, and wage counter warfare. But the first thing we need to remember is the truth: We're not the problem. They are.
[Post placed on top until noon.]